I can still feel the ghost of that splinter in the meat of my thumb. It was a tiny thing, a jagged sliver of old-growth cedar that had been hiding in a fence post for 86 years until I decided to ‘inspect’ its integrity with a bare hand. Pulling it out took 16 minutes of focused, surgical breath-holding, but the relief was immediate, a sharp clarity that usually only comes after a fever breaks. It got me thinking about the irritants we build into our modern lives-the high-tech solutions that act like splinters in the side of the earth, festering until the ground eventually pushes them back out.

I’m standing today in a coastal cemetery where the air tastes like salt and damp decay. To my left is a retaining wall built in 1936. To my right is its younger, more expensive brother, a concrete block structure barely 6 years old. The contrast is embarrassing. The new wall is leaning at a precarious 16-degree angle, its face marred by a hairline fracture that looks like a map of a dying river. The old wall, a dry-stacked masterpiece of local granite, hasn’t moved an inch. It sits there with the heavy, unbothered confidence of a mountain. We like to think we’ve conquered physics with our chemistry, but gravity doesn’t care about our patents.

The Architecture of Breath

Dry-stacking is an exercise in 366-day patience. There is no mortar. There is no glue. There is only the calculated friction of stone upon stone, a puzzle where every piece is held in place by the collective weight of the whole. If the earth heaves-and it always heaves, at least 6 millimeters every winter-the stones shift. They rub shoulders. They settle into a new, more comfortable position. They breathe. The modern concrete wall, rigid and arrogant in its rebar cage, refuses to move. When the hydrostatic pressure builds up behind it after a 6-inch rainstorm, the wall has no choice but to break. It’s a tragic metaphor for how we build everything now-rigid, brittle, and destined for a spectacular collapse.

I’ve seen the way we pour millions into ‘smart’ materials while ignoring the dumb intelligence of the rock. We mistake speed for progress. We mistake the absence of labor for efficiency. It’s a specific kind of arrogance to think that a 6-month-old polymer is going to outperform a stone that has been being compressed by the earth for millions of years. I once made a mistake early in my career, suggesting a client use a poured concrete foundation for a terraced garden instead of following the existing stone line. It cracked within 16 months. I felt like a fraud, and I suppose I was. I was trying to solve a geological problem with a hardware store solution.

The Dignity of Longevity

We often look at these old-world techniques as quaint or ‘artisanal,’ a word that has been ruined by people selling $26 loaves of bread. But there is nothing quaint about a wall that survives a hurricane that levels every modern house on the block. There is nothing ‘cute’ about a drainage system that hasn’t clogged since the 1906 floods. This is high-performance engineering that just happens to be made of mud and sweat. Our modern materials are often just a way to hide our lack of skill. We use mortar to fill the gaps that should have been closed by better stone selection. We use screws where we should have used joinery. We are masking the symptoms of a dying craft.

“

The ground wants that space,’ he says, wiping sweat from a brow that has seen 56 summers of hard labor. ‘So the wall gives it to him. But it doesn’t fall. It just bows.’

I think about my own life, how often I try to be the concrete wall, standing rigid against the pressures of my $676-a-month anxieties and the 16 different deadlines on my calendar. I end up cracking. I end up failing. Maybe the secret isn’t more rebar. Maybe the secret is being more like the granite-finding my weight, finding my center, and letting the water pass through the gaps.

Infrastructure as Funeral

We found an old drainage culvert made of flat slate. It was perfect. It was dry. It was functioning exactly as intended after a century of neglect. The developers tore it out anyway, replacing it with 16-gauge plastic pipe that will likely degrade and collapse when the first heavy truck rolls over it. They called it ‘infrastructure upgrades.’ I called it a funeral. We are burying our history under a layer of cheap, shiny trash, and we wonder why our cities feel so hollow.

A Return to Obligation

I am not saying we should abandon progress in medicine or communication. But we need to stop assuming that the new way is the better way simply because it’s newer. We need to look back at the 46 generations of builders who came before us and ask what they knew that we’ve forgotten. They knew that the best materials are usually the ones you find under your feet. They knew that a job worth doing is worth doing at a pace that allows for excellence.

When I finally got that splinter out of my thumb, I held it up to the light. It was a tiny sliver of history… It had survived decades of weather and rot, only to remind me that the old ways still have teeth. We can try to ignore the hidden intelligence of craftsmanship, but it will always find a way to make itself felt.